Who is a better cartoon father? Stan Smith, ...

Simpsons FAQ | 31.08.2010 3:00 | 8 Comments

Which of these cartoon dads have the better shown and family?

my choices are Homer Simpson, Hank Hill and Stan Smith

8 Comments on “ Who is a better cartoon father? Stan Smith, ...”

comments rss | trackback url

Stephanie

31.08.2010 3:52

hank hill, he isnt a total spaz. he cares about his kid and isnt messing him up. he doesnt neglect bobby

Miko Man Man

31.08.2010 4:25

Homer simpsons is my favorite
peter is my second favorite
stan is my third
i don’t like king of the hill as much, so i dont really like hank hill

Tahkyn Z

31.08.2010 5:03

I think Homer Simpson. He is a clumsy oaf at times but he does care for his family, and will often redeem himself and situations he has put them through. Homer has his failings but is genuinely a good dad.

Peter Griffin is like Homer, but learns nothing from his mistakes and is disconnected with his family to an extent.

Stan Smith is too busy being a hero and his family cope without his often divided attention. He wouldn’t be missed for a bag of chips if aliens abducted him.

Hank Hill is also a genuinely good father who cares about his family. He is, however, more boring that Homer and thus, Homer wins.

piccolo0122

31.08.2010 6:02

I would Stan Smith, mostly because I would be friends with that guy. His Kids irritate him but the overall message of the show is taking care of his children even if they don’t share his hopes and dreams. He’s taken a bullet for Haley and she is the most different then him.

Then I would choose Homer Simpson, he’s probably had the most heart warming episodes regarding his wife and kids but some times I just think he should ditch them, I mean they are so annoying and lame especially in the later seasons. It use to be Marge was to good for Homer now its will Homer please leave that nagging over bearing woman and her stupid kids so he can have his own show? Please? Yeah that show has been on to long…..what was the question?

Hank Hill, there is just something about “That boy ain’t Right” that stopped being funny to me. At first it seemed all funny because “That boy ain’t Right” was Bobby being obsessed with fruit pies or thinking he was a shaman ha ha ha. Then it became bobby wanting to be a comedian or Bobby feeling football isn’t the most important thing in the world. Football not important! THAT BOY AIN’T RIGHT. No Hank, your old world views of what a real man is, isn’t right. Him loving his dog more then his wife and son is also a big bleh for me. With Hank Bobby will never be right or accepted by his own dad unless he lives exactly like Hank and the show wants you to feel sorry for Hank but applaud him for not ditching Bobby by a Highway for “not being right ” No thanks, I can’t stand Hank or any person with over bearing control issues like that.

Peter Griffin in dead last, has he ever cared about his kids? He shot his own baby in the face followed by a bad pun, really don’t have to bring up the Meg situation. Terrible, absolutely Terrible father. Well I guess to be fair it was all a simulation. The stewie killing.

Well you seem to have got me Rambling. Good Question.

tigerspud

31.08.2010 6:51

hank hill! a dedicated strickland propane employee for 20 years he also puts up with his just married niece & her redneck husband & their baby daughter,he has endured his father cottons passing also when his son bobbys ventriloquist dummy is destroyed he made a new dummy that looked like bobby

You All Have Is Zoidberg!

31.08.2010 7:41

That’s like comparing apples to oranges… and kumquats and tangelos. I like Hank Hill. I know the humor in “King of the Hill” isn’t as broad as the others, and that’s what makes it genuinely funny. Homer comes in second, only because throughout the 20 years is isn’t always the funniest. Stan Smith comes in third (no reason). And DEAD BOTTOM OF THE LIST WITH ZERO POINTS is Peter Griffin. Fart jokes, crap jokes, murder of children, friends and acquaintances, makes this a show (even though I watch it from time to time) that I won’t shed any tears over when it is cancelled. Hopefully soon.

sleepybeeach

31.08.2010 8:29

Hank Hill by far

Homer is my fav, and Peter is a close 2nd, but in terms of being a father Hank Hill is miles above the rest

Hank is the only father who takes time to encourage his son, and even accept him for the way he is

Instead of the other three who are usually too busy persuing whatever crazy adventure they feel like

Dee T

31.08.2010 9:10

Peter Griffin He is just funny I mean just look at him

Leave a Reply

*

Comic Book Vendors | Rave Comics | Simpsons Lookalikes | Simpsons Fans | About The Simpsons | Simpsons Television | The Comic Book Blog | Comics for Free | The Grim Avenger | The Gotham Knight | Batman Directory | Batman Arcade | Comic Book Drawings | Watchmen Games